Towers of strength or vulnerable weaklings? Representing the Cornish miner

Lena Ferriday, ‘A sense of class: representations of embodiment in Cornwall’s subterranean environments, ca.1850-1910’, Environment and History 31.2 (2025), pp. 213-34.

Lena Ferriday here adopts the concept of embodiment, fashionable among historians in the past few decades, to study how Cornish miners were viewed in Victorian times. This entails giving greater space to the role of sensory experiences and the physical body. (See also here.) Attention to embodiment has sometimes been seen as part of a turn away from class and other more structural factors, reflecting a wider shift since the later twentieth century from society-wide factors to a focus on the individual. Yet more recently there has been a detectable desire to bring those structural factors back into the equation.

This is exactly what Ferriday does in this fascinating article, noting how reactions to the sensory environments found in nineteenth century Cornish mines were both shaped by class and shaped class interactions. At the heart of her study are the bodies of underground (and therefore male) miners. As she notes, they were represented by contemporaries (and since) in two principal ways. Cornish miners were either examples of stoic masculinity, paradigms of strength actively controlling their underground environment. Alternatively, they were passive victims of sickness, experiencing short life spans, vulnerable to lung disease and risking unpredictable accidents in dangerous environments.

Ferriday deconstructs these competing and often paradoxical narratives by examining the miners through the lens of class and by comparison with middle class visitors. In doing so she reminds us that the mine was not a homogenous place. It contained varying ‘sensescapes’, with differing effects involving touch, sound and sight. Moreover, the accounts of middle class visitors reveal a stratified ‘sensescape’ with micro-environments experienced differently by visitors and workers.

In working spaces and on the ladders descending into or ascending from the depths, the visitor was impressed by the ability of the working miners daily to withstand arduous conditions that were inconceivable for the visitor. The focus here was on working class masculinity and strength, both physical and moral and the endurance of the miner. In their working places the  miner was regarded as superior to the visitor.

Yet in two other environments, expertise was inverted. The first was in mining levels under the sea. Here, the visitors commented on the fear of flooding expressed by miners, no longer confident and fearless but in awe of the power of nature. In contrast, the middle class observer could adopt a more detached but emotional response able to appreciate the poetry of the waves crashing mere yards above their heads.

The second environment was ‘back to grass’. When miners emerged exhausted from their long climb up the ladders, they were miraculously ‘medicalised’. At the point when they were no longer productive they reverted to being merely exhausted, sweaty workers gasping for air. Again in contrast, the middle class observer, not having spent a core beating the borer, was able to appreciate a sense of freedom and enjoy movement and liberation on reaching fresh air.

As Lena Ferriday concludes, the relations of men and environments in Cornish mines ‘reveal … much about Victorian class interactions’.